Monday, December 6

Calls for aboriginal woman to lead B.C. missing women inquiry dominate public forum | Vancouver, Canada | Straight.com

Calls for aboriginal woman to lead B.C. missing women inquiry dominate public forum | Vancouver, Canada | Straight.com
By Yolande Cole,

Calls for an aboriginal woman to lead the upcoming provincial inquiry into missing women dominated a public forum in Vancouver today (December 5).

Audience members at a forum on violence against women in the Downtown Eastside voiced concerns about next year’s missing women commission of inquiry, to be led by former B.C. attorney-general Wally Oppal.

“We’re concerned about a couple of things,” Fay Blaney of the Aboriginal Women’s Action Network told the Straight following the event. “One is that Oppal is heading it – that’s a serious concern because we see it as a conflict of interest. This is a guy that didn’t want any inquiry to happen, and now he’s in there, and the second concern is the absolute lack of consultation with the aboriginal community on what the inquiry should be looking at.”

Vancouver activist and Walk4Justice organizer Gladys Radek said families should be included in the inquiry process.

“Right now at this time, we feel that the families are not being included in any of the decision-making for this public inquiry,” Radek told audience members at the forum.

“We feel that it’s important that the families are the ones that we’re speaking about.”

Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, the president of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, supported calls from several speakers at the forum for an aboriginal woman to lead the inquiry.

“We have to remove Oppal as quickly as possible, and replace him with somebody more appropriate, and we have to broaden the terms of the reference, and it has to be through a consultation process that never happened”, Phillip told the Straight. “It’s got to happen soon.”

Oppal, who also attended the forum at the Aboriginal Friendship Centre, defended the inquiry process in an interview with the Straight following the event.

“The families are involved in a major way,” he said. “We’ve had a number of lawyers who have come to us – they’re going to seek standing on behalf of the families, and I want the families to get involved.”

Oppal dismissed claims that he was originally against an inquiry.

“The only time I opposed the inquiry was when the trial was going on,” he added. “You cannot have a trial under our law and an inquiry at the same time.”

The forum was hosted by MP Libby Davies, MLA Jenny Kwan and Vancouver city councillor Ellen Woodsworth.

“There has been so much grief and tragedy in this neighbourhood, about what’s happened to the missing women, about how the situation was ignored for so long,” Davies said. “For too long it’s been swept under the rug and ignored.”

Speakers at the event also called for the causes of violence against women to be addressed, and for the abolition of prostitution.

“It seems like the inquiry is going to be looking at largely the police...and there isn’t really any looking at the root causes that bring aboriginal women into being in the Downtown Eastside, being in situations of dire poverty. And people here spoke about child apprehension and our experiences in residential school – all of those things are not going to be even considered,” Blaney told the Straight

“We need abolition of prostitution first and foremost, and to look at our circumstance and how aboriginal women are such vulnerable citizens in a rich country like Canada.”

Sunday, December 5

Economic hard times cast shadow over women - thestar.com

Economic hard times cast shadow over women - thestar.com

December 06, 2010

Eileen Morrow

{{GA_Article.Images.Alttext$}}

Dean Rohrer Dec. 6. 2010

Dean Rohrer/Newsart

Today is the National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women in Canada. Typically on this day each year, there is a lot of remembrance. Action is another matter.

Fears are that this trend may continue, if not increase, now that governments are flagging austerity at every level. That would be dangerous because research and experience show that violence against women rises during tough economic times.

The observance of that terrible day in 1989 when Marc Lepine stalked and murdered 14 women at Montreal’s l’École Polytechnique is, regrettably, an opportunity to keep ongoing violence against women on the public policy agenda.

Political representatives countywide wear the symbolic rose button or white ribbon to show their support, but they don’t often announce significant public funding or action to mirror the anger and angst of the vigils or the everyday reality of violence in the lives of women and girls.

During a recession, the fear is that violence against women will rise while meaningful action on the issue will fall. That worry is well-placed.

The media have already reported increasing calls by women to crisis lines and police. Catholic Family Services in Durham region reported a 24 per cent increase in referrals for domestic violence in the last three months of 2008. The Canadian Mental Health Association in London reported a rise in domestic violence in the spring of 2009. Brockville reported a 100 per cent increase in domestic violence calls to police during that period.

In the spring of 2009, stories about a stunning increase in calls to shelters in Calgary, where the recession hit hard, were reported in newspapers across Canada — a 200 per cent increase in one year; a 300 per cent increase in the month before the stories ran.

A spot survey just conducted by the Ontario Association of Interval and Transition Houses bears out the continuing trend toward increasing calls for help, despite predictions that the economic outlook is positive and recovery has started.

A comparison of service delivery in the years 2007 and 2010 in 15 women’s shelters across the province shows that requests for support have increased, albeit not as dramatically has those of Alberta.

Crisis calls increased by almost 15 per cent between the two years; admissions of women and children increased by 20 per cent. Shelters had to “turn away” 44 per cent more women and children in 2010 than in 2007 because they were full. In smaller towns with fewer services, the shelters faced double the demand of larger cities.

Each year, the women’s shelter association gathers the names of women and children murdered in situations where an intimate partner is either charged or commits suicide. In 2008 and 2009, the total was 16 for each year. In 2010 (up to the present) it is 21.

Admittedly, the numbers are not scientific and cannot be decisively linked to the recession, but they are troubling. Still more troubling, however, is the possibility that governments will overlook the need to increase support for women rather than to freeze or lower to meet the demands of austerity.

We have been there.

In the Mike Harris era of the mid-90s, cuts to women’s services and broad social programs such as social assistance and housing, forced many women to stay in abusive relationships. Murders of women increased in Canada, primarily in Ontario. Services in Ontario are still struggling to recover.

The mid-90s was a time of growing government restraint both federally and provincially, somewhat like today but far less acute. The global economy had not yet failed.

Nationally, Prime Minister Stephen Harper has been clear that national priorities are fixed on cost-cutting and reducing the $45.4 billion federal deficit. The Province of Ontario also has an $18.7 billion dollar deficit to address.

Both federally and provincially, all political parties are in election campaign mode. The timing of the federal election is a guessing game; some are guessing spring of next year. The Ontario election is fixed for Oct. 6, 2011.

As a result, no one knows which political party will be responsible for ultimately guiding the country and the province back to economic stability. What is clear, however, is that right now is the time to raise issues of women’s human and equity rights, not when an election is finally called.

In the noise of election campaigning that is now a daily exercise for politicians, it is hard for women and children to be heard above the din. It seems harder still, sadly, to make the case that their lives should trump the HST, hydro billing or gasoline prices in the political and public discourse.

Public policy that primarily serves cost-cutting and austerity, however, may ultimately result in more violence against women and their children at a time when government should protect the human and equity rights threatened by massive economic shifts.

For Dec. 6 to be truly meaningful, it must be observed not just with remembering women, but with promising not to forget them when governments divvy up the tax dollars paid by women and men for the programs and equality measures needed to stop violence against women.

VPD deputy chief clarifies his comments

VPD deputy chief clarifies his comments

Re: Lead Pickton investigator breaks silence, Nov. 27

I am writing to support Inspector Don Adam's defence of the extraordinary work of his Missing Women Task Force (Evenhanded) and to clarify comments attributed to me that give the appearance of conflict between my report on behalf of the VPD and the work of the team Inspector Adam led.

As I said upon the release of the VPD report into the Missing Woman/Pickton investigation, "While [the Review] includes the involvement of the RCMP during those years, it does not deal with the joint investigation called Project Evenhanded that took over the Pickton investigation.

" . . . The Team Commander of Project Evenhanded, Inspector Don Adam, was one of very few people anywhere in Canada who could have led that incredibly complex and large investigation to its successful conclusion.

"Not only did he have the very onerous responsibility as leader, he stepped in to the interrogation chair to obtain key admissions from Pickton. That team's work was extraordinary."

The story in The Vancouver Sun suggests that I was critical of the work of Project Evenhanded because I had written, "The investigation of Pickton before February 2002 was inadequate and a failure of major case management."

That sentence was clearly directed toward the Coquitlam RCMP's failings after the summer of 1999, not Evenhanded, which wasn't formed until 2001 and didn't investigate Pickton until 2002.

The VPD looks forward to clarification of these and related issues at the Public Inquiry, and to the release of the RCMP's official internal review to complement ours, so that police in B.C. and elsewhere can learn from previous errors to improve our collective practices, and so that such tragic circumstances are not repeated.

Doug LePard

Deputy chief constable,

Vancouver Police Department

Fallout from Pickton murders will continue to ripple across Canada in 2011 - Winnipeg Free Press

Fallout from Pickton murders will continue to ripple across Canada in 2011 - Winnipeg Free Press

VANCOUVER - The families of Robert Pickton’s victims finally got something to bury this year.

The process of returning the remains of the 26 women Pickton was accused of killing began in late summer, after the Supreme Court of Canada ended the legal proceedings in the case by refusing to grant him an appeal.

But advocates for marginalized women have continually fought — often fruitlessly — to ensure the case becomes more than just a collection of macabre stories of lives disposed by a dullard of a man who gained serial-killer celebrity.

In the years since Pickton’s victims vanished, while others disappeared from a lonely stretch of northern B.C. highway and still more went missing from Edmonton, Winnipeg and city streets across Canada, at no time have policy makers been paying more attention.

And potentially explosive challenges to Canada's prostitution laws working their way through courts — cases with roots in the Pickton killings — could force authorities to act.

"We're not going for changes just in and around the Vancouver area," said Gladys Radek, a Vancouver woman who started Walk4Justice, a cross-Canada march to draw attention to the phenomenon of missing and murdered women, by some estimates, up to 500 country-wide.

"We're going for municipal and provincial and federal changes in the judicial system so this won't happen again."

Radek's niece, Tamara Chipman, disappeared in 2005 and is among at least 18 women who have gone missing over four decades along the so-called Highway of Tears, between Prince Rupert and Prince George in northern British Columbia.

In Pickton's case, the legal proceedings ended in July when the Supreme Court of Canada denied his appeal and upheld his convictions on six counts of second-degree murder.

The next week, the B.C. Crown stayed 20 outstanding charges against Pickton, meaning those cases won't go to court. It also meant it is highly unlikely Pickton will ever be charged with the deaths of six more women whose DNA was found on his farm.

Prosecutors argue there would be no point because Pickton is already serving life in prison, but Joel Boen said their decision means Pickton will likely die without ever again having to hear his mother Yvonne's name.

Yvonne Boen is one of six women whose DNA was found on Pickton's farm for whose deaths he has never been charged.

"He killed her and that's the end of the story," Boen, 25, said in an interview earlier this year from his home in Saskatchewan.

But it hasn't been.

A long-demanded inquiry into the Pickton case was announced in September.

In October, provincial justice ministers and their federal counterpart acknowledged that the cases of missing and murdered women haven't been given the attention they deserve.

And later that month, the federal government ponied up $10 million over two years for a Missing and Murdered Aboriginal Women initiative.

Alan Young, an Osgoode Hall law professor in Toronto, said the Pickton case was part of the genesis for him and a team of lawyers to challenge Canada's laws against prostitution.

They won in the fall after successfully arguing in Ontario Superior Court the law forces prostitutes — overwhelmingly women — to work in unsafe conditions that make them vulnerable to predators like Pickton. The government has until April to appeal the ruling.

Young said that in 1990, an effort to challenge the same laws at Canada's high court failed. The justices concluded laws that force prostitutes off the street but don't allow them to move indoors were contradictory but not unconstitutional.

"The court sort of threw up its hands and said, 'Well, you know, it's a bit bizarre, a bit odd' — these are the words they used — 'but there's no constitutional problem when all you're saying is the law is strange,'" Young said in an interview.

The Pickton case proved differently.

"It was irrationality leading to the killing fields," said Young.

It's not just Pickton's case bolstering the fight, Young said. Eighteen women have gone missing or been found murdered along the Highway of Tears, an RCMP task force in the Edmonton area has 82 similar cases between Calgary and Edmonton to investigate and a task force in the Winnipeg area has a list of more than 30.

Most are sex-trade workers.

"It is epidemic," said Young. "It is a problem that is inherent in telling people that you can do this business but you can't do it in a safe setting."

The prostitution case is bound to end up before the Supreme Court of Canada. Young expects to be arguing at the Ontario Appeal Court next year and hopes to have a definitive decision from the country's highest court by the end of 2012.

He said he'll be watching the Pickton inquiry to see if Commissioner Wally Oppal concludes that Canada's laws are partly to blame for putting Vancouver women in the serial killer's hunting ground.

Oppal — a former B.C. attorney general who, before politics, spent more than two decades as a judge — will start hearings early next year looking into how Vancouver city police and the RCMP conducted the investigation into the dozens of women that went missing from the streets of Vancouver's Downtown Eastside.

He's expected to hear angry testimony about how family members were ignored or insulted when they tried to report their loved ones missing; how a turf-war between Vancouver police and the RCMP kept them from working together and how 1998 murder charges against Pickton were stayed, allowing him to continue killing until he was arrested again in 2002.

Oppal is confident his report will lead to better policing nationwide. One Ontario force, he said, is sending a deputy chief to monitor the inquiry.

But he was cautious about suggestions he should also look at the circumstances that force women onto the streets in the first place.

"I don't know that we can go that far because the issues can go and on," he said in an interview.

"We know that there are very complex issues regarding poverty, disenfranchised people, people who have historically lived in poor areas like the Downtown Eastside.

"I don't know how far we can go into delving into some of those complex background materials."

Oppal, whose report is due by Dec. 31, 2011, noted the RCMP have over a million documents on missing women.

Kathy King is wearied by it all.

Her 22-year-old daughter, Cara, went missing in Edmonton in 1997.

King, who now works with women at risk and speaks at so-called "john schools" in Edmonton, phoned four times in a week to report her daughter missing, but no formal report was made until she specifically asked for one.She gave all the information she knew about her daughter's last whereabouts, an admittedly sketchy picture of someone she loved but who had fallen into a high-risk life.

"So then I said, well, now what do we do? And the person said 'Now we wait for a body.'"

King said police procedures in Edmonton have changed significantly since then. The RCMP and the Edmonton police established Project Kare to investigate missing women in Edmonton and Calgary, leading to a murder conviction against Thomas Svekla.

There have been no arrests in Cara's case. King said the years of waiting and hoping and planning for a trial that never came are behind her.

"It would be nice to have some answers, but I think I've come to accept that I probably won't."

Edmonton police now have procedures to treat reports of those missing more seriously butKing said too much of it — even the Pickton inquiry — is after the fact.

She noted the latest tally for the Pickton legal proceedings and investigation is $103 million.

"Where is the money to help these women get off the street? Service organizations are struggling for a pittance. The legal system has the ability to produce millions of dollars for their own process."

Then she paused, apologetic for sounding negative.Initiatives like Project Kare and the Pickton inquiry are great steps, she said.

"But they're just such drops in the ocean."

Find this article at:
http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/canada/breakingnews/fallout-from-pickton-murders-will-continue-to-ripple-across-canada-in-2011-111347354.html